Shopping cart is empty.

Birchbark Blog

Victim of Narrative

Louise Erdrich - Sunday, January 31, 2010
Our first book and supper club selection was Too Much Happiness, by Alice Munro.  I chose the book because I am a great admirer of Alice Munro and because I love short stories.  She never lets me down.  Mordant, ordinary, strange, funny, offhandedly sublime.  The two nights of book club discussion were so much better than I'd feared (as an introvert).  The people who came were tremendous and they had loads to say so I didn't have to carry the conversation at all.  Elation!  And I must say that the dinner by Kenwood Cafe was utterly delicious and left me warm and happy.  But was there too much happiness?  Well, the title is found in the last story of the book -- possibly the last words of a female mathematics genius.   Too much happiness, indeed.

Yet my distress over my addiction continues, and I seek some affirmation that will free me from the endless Aubrey/Maturin series of sea novels about The British Navy, a series well known as the tar baby of narrative (too much boredom?  Alas, no, vertiginous sea battles!  Utterly compelling characters, both male and female)  I've known relationships to founder on these rocks.  Marriages to beat against the lee shore of these novels and succumb.  Once you've started, with Master and Commander (forget the movie), you'll be keel hauled right in and there goes your winter.  You'll be a victim of narrative.

Coming up in May: the publication of Mohamed's Ghosts, by the young old-school prize-winning journalist Stephan Salisbury.  His book is about all of us -- victims of narrative following 9/11.  He cared to think about what was happening to the ordinary people who belong to a mosque, struggle to be American and to follow their beliefs as well.  This is a wrenching and outrageous story of our own shadow country conjured out of fear.

If I can unstick myself from Patrick O'Brian I will let you know how I did it.  I'm going to check out a 12 step sea novel program . . .  
Comments
Anonymous commented on 02-Feb-2010 01:23 PM
hoka hey! fight the good fight against surfeit of PO'Brian. My wife and i love the dog page-- how about a dog blog? next time we come to Minn/StPaul, we'll drop by (we're in Los Angeles).
Marlee Atkinson commented on 12-Feb-2010 11:43 AM
Louise,

Just recently heard about your new novel (which I will order from Birchbark), and wanted to send out a congrats to you from Austin Peay State University. We all miss you and hope the best for you in the coming years. I must admit that your visiting was one of the best experiences of my college education. Thank you, thank you, thank you! -Marlee Atkinson (the redhead)
Scarlet commented on 19-Feb-2010 02:33 AM
Honestly, there is no escaping Aubrey/Maturin. I devoured the series three years ago and now I'm listening to them (wonderfully read by Simon Vance). It has launched me on a hopeless Napoleonic Wars and sea novel obsession. I thought that surely I would be tired of it by now, but the fascination continues.
ann commented on 09-Mar-2010 08:22 AM
Addiction is as addiction does-I want to suffer from Tiger Woods
illness. Alas millions of dollars are not coming my way right now.
I do enjoy your illustrations as in your National Geographic book and hope that you continue this expression of your thoughts..Alice Munro's book has so many stories that were published earlier and I did read some of them and what is your next selection for discussion?
P S Susan's hospitality impressed me and your store is wonderful !
Post a Comment!

Canoe Family

Recent PostsRSS


Tags

Chitra Divakaruni Emily Johnson The Porcupine Year Anishinabe British Navy 2666 gratitude Mohamed's Ghosts Wendy Makoons Geniusz Remarkable Trees post holiday Gail Caldwell pilgrims Islam north dakota Gary Clement city of books gardens graphix This Green World cafe joy Vic Glover Light in August Alice Munro Fireworks Patrick O'Brian Book Review friends Czech Writer Tar Sands Keystone XL Collective Denial Unnatural Disasters Aza Climate Change Chickadee NACDI:All My Relations Native People Makoons bill mckibben favorite tree how good looking you are The Birchbark House japan germany Up Late Again Anton Treuer Keepers of the Trees Stephen Salisbury sweden Louise monkey in a dryer Rare Books More Remarkable Trees favorite dog Nero spring birchbark house series The Transition Handbook customers cafe closing aquifer H2Oil Brown Dog ptsd Kate DiCamillo Guthrie Theater Minnesota Peak Oil Empire of the Summer Moon The Farmer's Daughter Minneapolis Keeping Heart on Pine Ridge devoted customers Beth Dooley photography Our Knowledge Is Not Primitive Easter Island Dogs Gryphon Press Wastepaper Philip Roth Too Loud A Solitude Greenland show your love Wolf Hall Botany Too Much Happiness Magers and Quinn local economy Interview Hillary Clinton The Game of Silence The Ojibwe neighborhood peculiar touches of green and gold Roberto Bolano Video National Book Award Kabul book and dinner club Master Butchers Singing Club thanks Aubrey/Maturin Jim Harrison knowledge Ojibwe The Resilient Gardener health care reform post holiday reads ependent anniversary leaves and snow Love President Obama Women and Trees language revitalization Ha Jin favorite book Catalyst Education italy Kenwood Gardens Tree Houses The Wealth of Nature The Round House Let's Take the Long Way Home Peak Water Milkweed Press trees S.C. Gwynne the most romantic city in the world Afghanistan fresh water Crushing Books Ice Dartmouth The Royal Prussian Library Bleak House World on the Edge Michael Jackson solstice, Thomas King The Blue Sky euphoria William Trevor france Ojibwemowin coyote Bill Moyers Journal Poetry Canada ireland adventure support buffalo School Gardens Native Arts tree books Green Team Anishinabemowin Nemesis china Alan Weisman mississippi Population Birchbark Books State Troopers Hilary Mantel boarding school Bohumil Hrabal incarnation Mankato Powwow Pembina twins Victory Gardens Zombies plants Small Bookstores as Commons green 350.org thank you friends E.L. Doctorow

Archive